In some cases (such as `ostree-sysroot-cleanup.c`), the surrounding
code would be substantially cleaner if it was also ported to
fd-relative, but I'm going to do that in a separate patch.
That way these patches are easier to review for mechanical
correctness. I used an Emacs keyboard macro as the poor man's
[Coccinelle](http://coccinelle.lip6.fr/).
⚠️ There is a notable spiked pit trap here around
`posix_fallocate()` and `errno`. This has bit other projects,
see e.g.
7bb87460e6
Otherwise the port was straightforward.
I'd like to encourage people to make OSTree-managed systems more
strictly read-only in multiple places. Ideally everywhere is
read-only normally besides `/var/`, `/tmp/`, and `/run`.
`/boot` is a good example of something to make readonly. Particularly
now that there's work on the `admin unlock` verb, we need to protect
the system better against things like `rpm -Uvh kernel.rpm` because
the RPM-packaged kernel won't understand how to do OSTree right.
In order to make this work of course, we *do* need to remount `/boot`
as writable when we're doing an upgrade that changes the kernel
configuration. So the strategy is to detect whether it's read-only,
and if so, temporarily mount read-write, then remount read-only when
the upgrade is done.
We can generalize this in the future to also do `/etc` (and possibly
`/sysroot/ostree/` although that gets tricky).
One detail: In order to detect "is this path a mountpoint" is
nontrivial - I looked at copying the systemd code, but the right place
is to use `libmount` anyways.
And change the command line to use it. rpm-ostree had a copy
of this code, and thus there's a clear reason to have an API.
While we're moving this into API, ensure the mtime on deploy is bumped
after an osname is created, so that daemons like rpm-ostree can notice
changes. (In reality, creating the directory should do this, but
let's be double sure)
This allows other processes (e.g. rpm-ostreed) to monitor for external
changes (e.g. if someone does `ostree admin undeploy`) in a relatively
sane fashion.
Specifically, I'm trying to fix:
https://github.com/projectatomic/rpm-ostree/issues/220
If ostree is run in a test setup where it operates as root in a tmp
directory, it might cause issues to flag the deployments as immutable.
The test harness might simply be doing an `rm -rf` (effectively the case
for gnome-desktop-testing-runner), which will then fail.
We add a new debug option to the ostree_sysroot object using GLib's
GDebugKey functionality to allow our tests to communicate to ostree that
we don't want immutable deployments.
This is a better followup to dc9239dd7b
since I wanted to do fsync-less checkouts in rpm-ostree too, and
replicating the "turn off fsync temporarily" was in retrospect just a
hack.
We can simply add a boolean to the checkout options.
https://github.com/GNOME/ostree/pull/172
Originally, a lot of the `fsync()` calls here were added for the
wrong reason - I was chasing a bug that ended up being the extlinux
bootloader not parsing 64 bit ext4 filesystems. But since it looked
like corruption, I tried adding a lot more `fsync()` calls.
All we should have to do is use `syncfs()`. If that doesn't work,
it's a kernel bug.
I'm making this change because skipping the individual fsyncs can be a
major performance win - it's easier for the FS to optimize, we do more
in parallel, etc.
https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=757117
This is a continuation of earlier work to drop the individual fsync on
files/directories in favor of relying on `syncfs()` for speed.
As part of that cleanup, I'm porting it to be fd-relative.
I feel relatively confident about this change given that this area of
the code has notable test suite coverage, although that code runs as
non-root.
I'm porting the deployment code to be fd-relative, but part of the
logic was using `GFile` to talk to `OstreeRepoFile` to determine the
"bootcsum" (boot config checksum) before checking out the file tree.
We can avoid having both code paths by checking out the tree first,
then looking at it on the filesystem.
There might be a race here in that we create new symlink files *after*
calling `syncfs`, and they are not guaranteed to end up on disk.
Rework the code so that we create symlinks before, and then only
rename them after (and `fsync()` the directory for good measure).
Additional-fixes-by: Giuseppe Scrivano <gscrivan@redhat.com>
Tested-by: Giuseppe Scrivano <gscrivan@redhat.com>
This still needs verification that we're fixing a real bug; but I'm
fairly confident this won't make the fsync situation worse.
https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=755595
New public function works like ostree_sysroot_cleanup() EXCEPT FOR
pruning the repository.
Under the hood, add _ostree_sysroot_piecemeal_cleanup() which takes
flags to better control what files are cleaned up. Both public cleanup
functions are now wrappers for _ostree_sysroot_piecemeal_cleanup() with
different flags.
These fsyncs were added for what turned out to be a fairly bogus
reason; I was hitting read errors from extlinux after upgrades and out
of conservatisim tried adding fsync calls, but the *actual* problem
was that extlinux didn't support 64 bit ext4. Now that at least for
Project Atomic hosts we're just targeting grub2, we can drop these
fsync calls and rely on `syncfs()` being both faster and catching any
errors.
For some sort of crazy reason, the `sync()` system call doesn't
actually return an error code, even though from what I can tell in the
kernel it wouldn't be terribly hard to add.
Regardless though, it is better for userspace apps to use `syncfs()`
to avoid flushing filesystems unrelated to what they want to sync. In
the case of OSTree, this does matter - for example you might have a
network mount point backing your database, and we don't want to block
upgrades on syncing it.
This change is safe because we're doing syncfs in *addition* to the
previous global `sync()` (a revision from an earlier patch).
Now because OSTree only touches the `/` mount point which covers the
repository, the deployment roots (including their copy of `/etc`), as
well as `/boot`, we should at some point later be able to drop the
`sync()` call. Note that on initial system installs we do relabel
`/var` but that shouldn't happen at ostree time - any new directories
are taken care of via `systemd-tmpfiles` on boot.
This will be used by rpm-ostree to unset the immutable bit temporarily
in order to do package layering. We could add an API to deploy a tree
without the immutable bit, but this is simpler.
subscription-manager has a daemon that runs in a confined domain,
and it doesn't have permission to write usr_t, which is the default
label of /ostree/deploy/$osname/deploy.
A better long term fix is probably to move the origin file into the
deployment root as /etc/ostree/origin.conf or so.
In the meantime, let's ensure the .origin files are labeled as
configuration.
rpm-ostree at least has the option to generate a tree with just that
instead of /boot, but while we were enumerating the latter, we'd still
return paths from /boot.
https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=740947
Use the pattern:
$PRETTY_NAME [$COMMIT_VERSION] (ostree[:$OSNAME][:$DEPLOYMENT_INDEX])
$OSNAME is only shown if there are multiple values.
$COMMIT_VERSION refers to the version tag in the commit's metadata.
$DEPLOYMENT_INDEX is only shown if no $COMMIT_VERSION is available.
https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=739416
We need basic support for UEFI - many newer servers don't support
BIOS compatibility mode anymore.
However, this patch only implements non-atomic because UEFI is FAT, and
we can't do the previous design for OSTree of atomic swap of
/boot/loader.
The Fedora/RHEL UEFI layout has the kernels on a "real" /boot
partition, and /boot/efi/EFI/$vendor just holds the grub2 UEFI binary
and grub.cfg.
Following this, /boot/loader is still on the OS boot partition, and we
still atomically swap it. This potentially paves the way to atomic
upgrades in the future.
https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=724246
In this approach, we drop a /etc/grub.d/15_ostree file which is a
hybrid of shell/C that picks up bits from the GRUB2 library (e.g. the
block device script generation), and then calls into libostree's
GRUB2 code which knows about the BLS entries.
This is admittedly ugly. There exists another approach for GRUB2 to
learn the BLS specification. However, the spec has a few issues:
https://www.redhat.com/archives/anaconda-devel-list/2014-July/msg00002.html
This approach also gives a bit more control to the admin via the
naming of the 15_ostree symlink; they can easily disable it:
Or reorder the ostree entries ahead of 10_linux:
Also, this approach doesn't require patches for grub2, which is an
issue with the pressure to backport (rpm-)OSTree to EL7.
Previously, in the case where a parent directory of a modified config
file was removed, we would throw an exception. This happens when
switching from a tree that has some software (e.g. firewalld), to one
that does not.
While it's nice to have this warning that your config file probably no
longer applies, there's no need to make it so...fatal.
It's particularly problematic that the only easy workaround is to
remove the config files from your current tree - which breaks
rollback.
The solution then is for for us to take ownership of the parent
directories too into the new /etc. Admins can clean up these files
afterwards at any time.
https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=734293
This fixes a regression introduced with https://git.gnome.org/browse/ostree/commit/?id=7baa600e237b326899de2899a9bc54a6b863943c
The original code in "ostree admin upgrade" had a comment:
/* Here we perform cleanup of any leftover data from previous
* partial failures. This avoids having to call gs_shutil_rm_rf()
* at random points throughout the process. */
But since I deleted that initial cleanup call, we *do* need to do the
cleanup during the process run. It turns out there are only a few
places this is necessary.
https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=733030
While looking to fix a different bug here, I found the current
state of things where we had a mix of fd-relative API versus not
frustrating.
Change the code around to consistently use *at, and also add some more
tests.
This prevents people from creating new directories there and expecting
them to be persisted. The OSTree model has all local state to be in
/etc and /var.
This introduces a compile-time dependency on libe2fsprogs.
We're only doing this for the root directory at the moment.
https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=728006
There's two halves to this; first, when we create an hierarchy, we
need to call fsync(). Second, we need to fsync again anytime after
we've modified a directory.
Trying to implement "rpm-ostree rollback", in the case where we have 2
deployments with the same bootconfig that we're reordering, we need to
write bootconfig, not just swap the bootlinks.
It turns out people sometimes want to be able to change the kernel
arguments. Add a convenient API to do so for the current deployment.
This will be used by Anaconda.
It's better if this is independent from the OstreeSysroot; for
example, a policy is active in a given deployment root at once, not
for a sysroot globally.
We can also collect SELinux-related API in one place.
Unfortunately at the moment there can be only one instance of this
class per process.
First, /var needs to be labeled at least once. We should probably
rearrange things so that /var is only created (and labeled) on the
first deployment, but this patch adds a /var/.ostree-selabeled file
instead.
Second, when doing the /etc merge, we compare the xattrs of the old
/usr/etc versus the current /etc. The problem with that is that the
policy has different labels for /usr/etc on disk than the real /etc.
The correct fix for this is a bit invasive - we have to take the
physical content of the old /usr/etc, but compare the labels as if
they were really in /etc.
Instead for now, just ignore changes to xattrs. If the file
content/mode changes, then we take the new file (including any changed
xattrs).
Bottom line: just doing chcon -t blah_t /etc/foo.conf may be lost on
upgrade (for now).
The trees as shipped come with /usr/etc, which should just be labeled
as usr_t. When we do a deployment, we need to relabel the copies of
the files we're making in /etc.
SELinux support is compile and runtime optional.
The "ordered hash" code was really just for kernel arguments. And it
turns out it needs to be a multihash (for e.g. multiple console=
arguments).
So turn the OstreeOrderedHash into OstreeKernelArgs, and move the bits
to split key=value and such into there.
Now we're not making this public API yet - the public OstreeSysroot
just takes char **kargs. To facilitate code reuse between ostree/ and
libostree/, make it a noinst libtool library. It'll be duplicated in
the binary and library, but that's OK for now. We can investigate
making OstreeKernelArgs public later.
https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=721136
The official way to add bootloader arguments to the current deployment
is to redeploy with --karg. However, doing so tripped up an
optimization made inside the deployment code to just swap the
bootlinks if we're keeping the same "bootcsum".
Change this optimization to look at the pair of (bootcsum, options).
This large patch moves the core xattr logic down into libgsystem,
which allows the gs_shutil_cp_a() API to copy them. In turn, this
allows us to just use that API instead of rolling our own recursive
copy here.
As noted in the new comment though, one case that we are explicitly
regressing is where the new /etc removes a parent directory that's
needed by a modified file. This seems unlikely for most vendors now,
but let's do that as a separate bug.
https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=711058
We need to use the full shutil_rm_rf() in order to actually delete
complete directories.
Test suite code based on a patch from Sjoerd Simons <sjored@luon.net>
https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=710097
This commit changes the sysroot API so that one can create arbitrary
new deployment checkouts, then commit them as one step. This is to
enable things like an automatic bisection tool which say create 50
deployments at once, then when done clean them up.
This also moves some printfs from the library into src/ostree.
If we had two deployments with different boot checksums, and were
trying to remove the one that was the same and add a new one (the
normal case), we'd end up assuming due to comparison with 0 that
we only needed to do the fast subbootversion swap.
Fix this by actually putting 1 where we really mean 1.
And update the tests to verify the fix; I have double-verified by
undoing the fix, and noting that the test fails.
https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=708351
The actual deployment checksum shouldn't be in there, because we may
just swap bootlinks, rendering the name of the old bootloader entry
file invalid. Thankfully nothing actually parsed the names of these
files, so let's just use the index.
This is just something I noticed on inspection; we should catch any
changes to /boot in the sync(), even though theoretically gio should
have done fdatasync().
Now that we have a real GObject for the sysroot, we have a convenient
place to keep track of 4 pieces of state:
* The current deployment list
* The current bootversion
* The current subbootversion
* The current booted deployment (if any)
Avoid requiring callers to pass all of this around and load it
piecemeal; instead the new thing is ostree_sysroot_load().
Gatis Paeglis
Colin Walters
Jonathan Lebon
Leandro Santiago
Matthew Barnes
Giuseppe Scrivano